The pair reunited to have one last conversation, and let’s just say the heated chat did not warm up that chilly Icelandic night. “What am I supposed to do?” Clayton snapped. “I’m still fighting because I was trying to convince you, but now it’s like—”
As a tearful Susie noted that she felt “s—ty,” she shared that she wasn’t sure of a better way to go about expressing her feelings. Clayton’s response?
“I’m just gonna be honest with you,” he coldly said. “In my eyes, you just invalidated everything that we had. If you cared so much about me, if you really actually thought I was the person…I think you would work through something like this.”
Let’s not gaslight the girl, Clayton. She said her peace.
By the end of the dramatic conversation—which included Clayton telling Susie that he didn’t know her anymore—the Bachelor escorted his former front-runner to a car.
We’re feeling very conflicted about where we stand in this messy breakup. How about you? Considering all of the above, where do you stand in this situation? Cast your vote below!